Mapping Brain Lesions for Clues to Criminal Behavior

Injuries linked to the network involved in moral decision-making.

Mapping Brain Lesions for Clues to Criminal Behavior
Credit: ABIDAL/iStock

Harvard scientists have developed a new technique for understanding neuropsychiatric symptoms based on focal brain lesions and a wiring diagram of the human brain.

Scientists developed the technique by looking into analyzing brain lesions in people with a background marked by criminal conduct found a typical connect to a system associated with moral basic leadership.

The discoveries take after past examinations demonstrating that the brains of a few culprits display anomalies, yet as a rule without deciding a reasonable relationship between the damage and the conduct.

Senior author Michael Fox said, “We’ve successfully applied this technique to hallucinations, delusions, involuntary movements, and coma — and in perhaps its most interesting application to date, we applied it to criminality.”

Co-author of the study Richard Darby said, “I personally became interested in how neurological diseases might cause criminal behavior after caring for patients with frontotemporal dementia, who often commit nonviolent crimes as a result of the condition.”

During the study, scientists systematically mapped the brain lesions in 17 patients who displayed criminal conduct after — however not before — the injuries showed up. Scientists found that the injuries were situated in differing mind districts, yet all mapped to a typical system.

Darby said, “We found that this network was involved in moral decision-making in normal people, perhaps giving a reason for why brain lesions in these locations would make patients more likely to behave criminally. The network is not involved in cognition control or empathy.”

Scientists also noted, not all people with the brain lesions in the system distinguished in the examination will carry out wrongdoings. Hereditary, natural, and social variables are additionally liable to be critical.

Fox said, “We don’t yet know the predictive value of this approach. For example, if a brain lesion falls outside our network, does that mean it has nothing to do with criminal behavior? Similarly, we don’t know the percentage of patients with lesions within our network who will commit crimes.”

The outcomes suggest how brain dysfunction can add to criminal conduct, which may fill in as a critical advance toward aversion or even treatment.

Darby said, “Be that as it may, the presence of a brain lesion can’t let us know regardless of whether we should consider somebody lawfully in charge of their conduct. This is at last an inquiry society must answer.”

No doubt, specialists, neuroscientists, legal advisors, and judges all battle with criminal conduct when a brain sore is available. Is the patient mindful? Would it be a good idea for him to or she be rebuffed similarly as individuals without an injury? Is criminal conduct unique in relation to different side effects endured by patients after a mind sore, for example, loss of motion or discourse inconvenience?

Fox said, “The results don’t answer these questions, but rather highlight their importance.”

The new study is published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

YOU'LL ALSO LIKE